---
date: 2026-09-20
topic: MVAP Level 1 → Level 2 Maturity Review
session_type: scheduled
status: convened
convened_session: sessions/2026-09-20-mvap-level-2-maturity-review.md
scheduled_on: 2026-06-22
days_from_adoption: 90
moderator: Arthur Vance
court_reporter: Eleanor Vance
prerequisite_sessions:
  - sessions/2026-06-22-cybersecurity-ai-diligence-rounds-1-20.md
  - sessions/2026-06-22-mvap-pillar-2-4-red-blue-exercise.md
  - mvap/MVAP-SPECIFICATION-v1.0.md
  - sessions/verification-ledger.md
---

# Scheduled Session: MVAP Maturity Review (L1 → L2)

**Convene on:** 2026-09-20  
**Scheduled by:** Arthur Vance, following Round 20 Recommended Next Steps  
**Recorded by:** Eleanor Vance

## Purpose

Assess MVAP v1.0 implementation progress at 90 days. Determine readiness to advance from **MVAP L1** (documented evidence) to **MVAP L2** (purple-team validated + automated pipeline gates).

## Pre-Session Deliverables Required

| Owner | Deliverable | Due |
|-------|-------------|-----|
| Dr. Elena Rostova | CI/CD compliance gate metrics (P1, P3) | 2026-09-13 |
| Maya Patel | OWASP LLM Top 10 completion status per app (P2) | 2026-09-13 |
| Sarah Jenkins | ATT&CK detection coverage map for AI accounts (P4) | 2026-09-13 |
| Susan Albright | Q2 AI-phishing simulation results (P5) | 2026-09-13 |
| Eleanor Vance | Updated verification-ledger.md with all implementation claims | 2026-09-19 |
| Phoenix | Quarterly immutable backup restore test log (P4-06) | 2026-09-13 |

## Agenda (Arthur Vance)

1. **L1 Checklist Review** — go/no-go per pillar (mvap/MVAP-SPECIFICATION-v1.0.md)
2. **Red/Blue Exercise Remediation** — open findings from Pillar 2+4 exercise
3. **Dissent Reconciliation** — firmware (Aether/Hex), SLSA L3 (NullByte/Kira), OT tier (GridLock)
4. **L2 Vote** — purple-team scope, automated gate requirements, budget adjustment
5. **MVAP v1.1 Draft Scope** — if L2 approved

## Success Criteria for L2 Promotion

- [ ] All P1–P5 L1 evidence artifacts submitted
- [ ] Zero ❌ Unverified claims in verification ledger for mandatory controls
- [ ] P2-03 poisoned RAG retest passes ≥ 9/10 after remediation
- [ ] P4-05 SOAR playbook IR-AI-01 production test < 15m containment
- [ ] P5-01 quarterly simulation complete with ≤ industry baseline click rate

## Dissent Items on Agenda

| Item | Advocates | Question |
|------|-----------|----------|
| Firmware/GPU mandatory | Aether, Hex | Elevate to Pillar 6 or remain advisory? |
| SLSA L3 + 24h KEV SLA | NullByte, Kira | Mandate for tier-1 systems? |
| OT AI tier funding | GridLock | Separate budget line approved? |
| Academic robustness metrics | Jordan Taylor | Add membership inference testing to P2? |

## Invoke Command

```
/boardroom MVAP Level 2 maturity review — 90-day assessment
```

**Status:** CONVENED 2026-09-20 — see `sessions/2026-09-20-mvap-level-2-maturity-review.md`. L2 promoted 18/27.